A $1.8 Million Fine Needs More Than a Form Letter.
A person can be subject to a final removal order and still be entitled to know why the government says she owes $1.8 million. That proposition should be ordinary. It became the center of a federal case after immigration authorities issued more than 103,000 civil penalties totaling roughly $84 billion, according to figures the Department of Homeland Security disclosed in July. On October 5, U.S. District Judge George O'Toole in Boston blocked the government's efforts to impose and collect the fines challenged in Maria L. v. Mullin. The reported ruling does not erase anyone's removal order or deny Congress's power to authorize civil penalties. It addresses a different act of government: converting a statutory penalty that turns on willful conduct into an enormous debt through boilerplate notices and an accelerated administrative process.
The statute contains a state of mind
Section 274D of the Immigration and Nationality Act, codified at 8 U.S.C. § 1324d, authorizes a daily civil penalty against a person subject to a final removal order who willfully fails or refuses to depart, make a timely good-faith application for necessary travel documents, or present for removal. It also reaches conspiracy or action designed to prevent or hamper departure. The original statutory ceiling was $500 per day. The government says inflation adjustments raised it to $998.
The word willfully is doing real work. A final order establishes that the government has legal authority to remove someone. It does not, by itself, establish why the person remains, what steps she took, whether departure was practically possible, whether travel documents were available, or whether her conduct met the statutory standard. Those questions may produce difficult facts and disputed answers. They cannot be skipped simply because the daily arithmetic is easy.
According to Reuters, the plaintiffs alleged that Immigration and Customs Enforcement used boilerplate forms without independently assessing whether nondeparture was willful or voluntary. Judge O'Toole agreed that the forms were legally inadequate because they lacked specific allegations explaining why each person's conduct warranted a penalty. That is an administrative-law holding with a basic adversarial insight: a recipient cannot meaningfully answer a charge that the government has not actually stated.
The scale makes the omission more serious, not less. DHS reported more than 103,000 fines totaling about $84 billion as of July. Reuters reports that some were calculated at $998 per day retroactively for as long as five years, producing demands of roughly $1.8 million. At that amount, a notice is not a nudge. It is a claim capable of overwhelming a household before collectability, settlement, or final judicial review is ever resolved.
Procedure is part of the penalty
The dispute also concerned how DHS and the Department of Justice changed the machinery used to impose these debts. Before June 2025, the agencies' own description says the process generally began with a notice of intention to fine, allowed 30 days for a sworn written defense and a request for an interview, permitted an extension for good cause, and offered an appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals after a decision.
The June 2025 interim final rule expressly set out to streamline that system. It created what the agencies called exclusive DHS procedures, transferred review away from the BIA, reduced the response period, and eliminated parts of the prior process. The rule became effective on publication while inviting comments afterward. The government defended speed as necessary to make a long-dormant enforcement authority workable at scale.
Reuters reports that Judge O'Toole held the agencies had not complied with required rulemaking procedure because they adopted the streamlined system without first giving the public a chance to comment. That conclusion is not the same as a judicial preference for a slower bureaucracy. Notice and comment forces an agency to disclose what it proposes, receive affected parties' evidence and objections, and explain the final choice. When a rule compresses the time to contest life-altering debt, procedure is part of the substance of what the government has done.
There is an institutional temptation here. If individualized analysis is expensive and the agency wants to issue six figures of penalties, standardization looks like capacity. But forms can standardize the presentation of a decision. They cannot supply the missing factual basis for one. A system becomes more efficient only in a superficial sense when it produces debts faster than it produces defensible reasons.
A civil label does not make the consequence modest
Immigration enforcement is often divided into boxes: removal in one, detention in another, civil monetary penalties somewhere off to the side. For the people receiving the notices, those boxes converge. A person may be contesting removal, pursuing another form of relief, trying to obtain travel documents, supporting a family, and facing a debt larger than any plausible lifetime capacity to pay.
The two individual plaintiffs in Maria L. proceeded under pseudonyms. Their counsel's case page says both had pending petitions that could allow them to become lawful permanent residents and could not afford the hundreds of thousands of dollars assessed against them. Those are the plaintiffs' allegations and counsel's account, not independent judicial findings about their ultimate immigration status or liability. They do illustrate why the factual basis matters. The government cannot treat continued presence as a complete answer when the statute asks whether the failure to depart was willful.
Judge O'Toole reportedly found that allowing collection to proceed would likely drive the plaintiffs, who were already in economically precarious positions, into insolvency. Insolvency is not merely a dramatic side effect. It changes housing, employment, credit, family stability, and the practical ability to retain counsel. A nominally civil enforcement tool can therefore alter a person's ability to navigate the very legal system that produced it.
None of this means a large civil penalty is categorically unlawful. Congress may attach serious consequences to willful violations, subject to constitutional and statutory limits. It means severity increases the need for accurate classification. If the government seeks a penalty that can financially erase a household, it should be able to identify the conduct, connect that conduct to the statutory element, and provide a real path to contest the charge.
What the ruling does not decide
The cleanest way to understand the decision is to identify what remains outside it. The ruling does not convert a final removal order into lawful status. It does not hold that Congress lacks authority to impose a failure-to-depart penalty. It does not establish that every person who received a notice has a valid defense. And it does not turn the allegations in the complaint into findings about every fine issued nationwide.
It does separate removal authority from penalty liability. The first asks whether the government may require departure. The second asks whether the person engaged in conduct that satisfies the penalty statute and whether the agency used a lawful process to decide it. Agencies frequently administer overlapping consequences, but one valid government action does not automatically prove the elements of another.
That distinction matters for lawyers reviewing an existing notice. The practical file is not limited to the amount demanded. It includes the precise statutory provision invoked, the date and status of the removal order, the period used in the calculation, the asserted facts supporting willfulness, the person's efforts to obtain documents or comply, service, response deadlines, prior administrative steps, and the scope of the court's relief. The October 5 ruling may materially affect those questions, but it should not be summarized to a client as though every debt has vanished or every immigration issue has been resolved.
The government may appeal, revise the forms, undertake new rulemaking, or attempt a process with more individualized support. Those possibilities make careful language important now. The immediate development is a federal district court ruling blocking the challenged fine policies and collection efforts, as Reuters reports. It is not the last word from every court or the end of the underlying enforcement authority.
The government still has to show its work
Mass administration needs forms, databases, and repeatable decisions. The law does not require every notice to become a treatise. It does require the agency to preserve the elements Congress enacted and the procedures law demands. When the relevant element is willfulness, a standardized statement that someone remained after an order is a conclusion looking for its facts.
There is a broader lesson here beyond immigration. Automated eligibility systems, fraud filters, tax assessments, benefits terminations, licensing sanctions, and civil penalties all create pressure to treat a system's output as the reason for the decision. It is not. A balance, score, or category can communicate what the government decided. Due process and administrative law still ask how it decided, what facts support the result, and whether the affected person had a meaningful opportunity to respond.
The attraction of mass penalties is that the number itself appears decisive. A $1.8 million demand suggests gravity before anyone examines its foundation. Judge O'Toole's ruling restores the order of operations. The government may have a powerful enforcement tool. Before it uses that tool against a particular person, it must allege the conduct the statute punishes and adopt the governing procedure lawfully. Scale does not eliminate that obligation. It is the reason to insist on it.
A final removal order may establish authority to remove. It does not, without more, establish willful nondeparture or a $1.8 million debt.
Sources and further reading
Primary and industry sources used to support this page. External guidance should be reviewed in context and for your jurisdiction.
- Reuters, U.S. judge blocks policy imposing immigration fines up to $1.8 millionOctober 6, 2026 report on Judge George O'Toole's ruling, the challenged notices and rulemaking process, DHS figures, the plaintiffs, and the reported scope of relief. DHS had not immediately commented.
- 8 U.S.C. § 1324d, Civil penalties for failure to departStatutory text identifying the final-order predicate, willfulness requirement, covered conduct, and original daily ceiling. The amount is adjusted for inflation.
- DHS and DOJ, Imposition and Collection of Civil Penalties for Certain Immigration-Related ViolationsJune 27, 2025 interim final rule describing the prior process, the agencies' enforcement history, the $998 inflation-adjusted daily amount, and the streamlined DHS procedures.
- Public Justice, Maria L. v. Mullin case pagePlaintiffs' counsel's description of the litigation and links to the complaint, stay motion, and class-certification motion. Its characterizations are advocacy, not independent findings.